Landfills May Be Greener Than Recycling, finds study

By Eco Guy 8:54am 5th October 2010
Recycling plastic bottles might not always be the most environmentally-friendly option for disposal, according to a study by an independent consultancy based near Zurich, Switzerland.

The carbon-footprint study, titled "PET’s carbon footprint: to recycle or not to recycle" has found that in communities with limited infrastructure, recycling a plastic bottle can actually result in a bigger carbon footprint than simply throwing it in a landfill.

"The footprint of recycling is lower than that of landfills only if at least half of the plastic ends up being valorised. That's right: only if about 50 percent or better of the used PET actually displaces production of new PET, will recycling deliver the lowest footprint," said Eric Johnson, one of the study's authors.

In typical curbside recycling programs, less than 50 percent of recovered PET eventually ends up as new plastic packaging.

However, the researchers did find that programs where bottles were taken back by the manufacturer, recycling services that required separate collection or bottle-deposits typically reported much higher displacement rates – some in the range of 75 percent.

Still, the authors say these findings aren't a reason to give up on recycling.

Instead, they hope their findings will encourage communities that already have a recycling infrastructure to increase used PET's displacement of new PET significantly above 50 percent through better collection and sorting techniques.

For communities that lack suitable recycling programs, the authors hope to dispel the common misconception that shipping plastics for recycling in other countries is just as harmful as landfilling.

"Yes, the transport adds to the footprint, but not nearly as decisively as displacement, said Johnson in The Ecologist. "If the travelling bottles end up substituting what would have been new PET, then the journey was well worthwhile."

One disappointing part of this study is that it seems to ignore the environmental impact of plastics once they do end up in the landfill.

As plastic bottles decay, they take up precious landfill space, leaching harmful chemicals into the ground and potentially polluting the soil and water. Because landfills are so tightly packed, some scientists are concerned that the rate of decay in landfills could be even slower than previously surmised, as the conditions are not optimal for breakdown (WiseGeek).

Related Content Tags: recycling, adaptive reuse, recycled design, recycled materials

Follow us on Facebook, click here!

Comments left

  • Mission Recycling said:

    This site is informative. I have learn a lot of things to consider. I didn't know some other things that you have mention. But thanks to you it helps me understand things that I might want to know.

    ON Fri, 8 Oct 10, 3:04pm probably from Philippines  Reply to this comment

  • Kirk Gibson said:

    It is my great pleasure to visit your website and to enjoy your excellent post here. I like that very much. I can feel that you paid much attention for those articles, as all of them make sense and are very useful. Thanks so much for sharing. I will be...

    ON Wed, 26 Oct 11, 7:25am probably from Australia  Reply to this comment

Add Coment

Got a question or comment about this?

Find what you were looking for?.. Not quite what you expected?.. Got a question to ask people?
Share your thoughts and use the form below to post a public comment right on this page.

Simple HTML is supported i.e <b> <i> etc. Excessive inline URL's, spam, ANY ads or swearing is blocked/removed quickly. youtube URL's get embedded.

Posting Terms & Conditions